Editorial: Should Moms And Children Be Separated By The State

Tools

Editorial: Should Moms And Children Be Separated By The State

Dan Garcia

This weeks editorial focuses on the children removed from the F.L.D.S. compound in Eldorado. KAUZ General Manager Mike De Lier asks if it was right to remove them.

"Regardless of your feelings about polygamy, should moms and children be separated by the state?" We asked this question in one of our daily polls on www.kauz.com.

You responded this way: YES -- 54 percent; NO -- 46 percent.

Pretty close!

We have to ask this question: "why so?" Why should the state assume parental control? To date, the state has not determined the name of the caller or validity of the call that triggered this whole episode.

Though we do not agree with the practice of polygamy -- aren't there also some rational concerns about the safety and well being of these children who have been taken from their mothers? Caring for off-spring is natural, complex and necessary. We need to ask another question: "How would you feel if the state came into your home, made a judgement call on your parenting and took your children?"

In the past the Children's Protective Services of Texas have had extreme issues of their own -- as concerns professionalism, maintaining the safety of children --- doing their jobs as mandated by the state.

There may not be a clear understanding at this time of all the issues and of all the consequences. So we are going to post the poll question again for a couple of days on the local news page and report the results back to you Monday during our regular newscasts. So if you are interested in this issue, please go to www.kauz.com and answer the question. You can also go to the "Editorials" Blog and give your opinions.

If you'd like to comment on this editorial, logon to www.kauz.com and head to the Editorial Blog Section and tell us what you think.

Saturday, May 17 at 5:27 AM Mr. Kennedy wrote ...

If you want the truth, go to the new FLDS website, the Truth Will Prevail.

Friday, May 16 at 2:36 AM Grandma wrote ...

Check out the new FLDS website The Truth Will Prevail. Anyone who reads this and still believes the CPS lies is truly a lost cause and a hopeless case.

Friday, May 16 at 1:53 AM Mr. Kennedy wrote ...

CPS abuse and lies regarding FLDS are slowly coming out. Soon, it will reach critical mass, and the People will realize that the Government does not have the children's "best interests" at heart, nor does CPS. Remember, all it takes is ONE anonymous phone call, and the Gestapo CPS can destroy your baby, children, family, FOREVER.

Saturday, May 10 at 2:33 AM Mr Kennedy wrote ...

This is the end of civilization. A tragedy of mythic proportions. Those CPS workers have some accounting to do, in the courts of the People, and in the final judgment day. May God have mercy on the Children, no one else seems to.

Thursday, May 8 at 9:27 PM Plato wrote ...

Who owns the youth controls the future. — Napoleon and many others, amongst them, Socrates (tongue firmly in cheek), Hitler and Lenin Give me your 4-year-olds, and within a generation I'll construct a Socialist State. — Vladimir Lenin First they came for the fathers, then for the mothers, and now for both parents in intact families. In the end all children will be in the care, custody and control of the State. — Walter H. Schneider

Wednesday, May 7 at 11:05 PM Mrs. Johnson wrote ...

CPS = Cruelest, most inhumane gang of thugs - who else can so ruthlessly rip infants and children from their mothers and families, and then claim they did it "in the child's best interest". Wake up, American - this happens all the time - perfectly happy, healthy children are stolen by the State, all because these government mooches need to justify their existence and get grants. Save the Children, Save the Families! Contact politicians, tell them this MUST STOP, BEFORE THEY TAKE YOUR CHILD!

Friday, Apr 25 at 3:33 PM kharris wrote ...

stop cps from trying to play God. those children and taking them from their mothers. This are good moms that need their children back.

Friday, Apr 25 at 2:38 PM Anonymous wrote ...

CPS have every right to take children when the parents refuse to protect them. Any mother who allows her daughter to have sex and become pregnant at 13 is an unfit mother. These mothers had a choice to get on a bus to a shelter with their chilren or back to their compound. They chose the compound and are now screaming about how their babies were "ripped" from their arms. If a man had sex with my 13 year old daughter...he would be in jail. What's the difference here?

Friday, Apr 25 at 11:24 AM JAK wrote ...

CPS is already overburdened and adding 420 plus more to the system! Where will they find "fosters" to care for these children as well as they are already being cared for. We may not agree with their practice of marrying girls too young, but the children are clean and being fed and cared for by their Mothers. I would certainly not like the state to come into my home and take my children based on what MAY be a false tip/report while ignoring a child on the street with no food and no care!

Friday, Apr 25 at 10:18 AM Montene Merchant wrote ...

Case in Amarillo caused by a baby sitting service. She allowed off free ^ testified in Court. CPS angry when questioned .. like a Gestapo Judge allowed atty for appeal which was upheld..then pulled atty we couldn't afford to hire one. Seldom does CPS pursue case when a good atty can be hired to fight their charge. Pick on mostly poor people. What about case just on news here? If CPS workers ever disciplined one never knows about it. case Amarillo baby died foster care, imm drop chrgs family poo

Friday, Apr 25 at 10:11 AM Montene Merchant wrote ...

My family has had dealings with CPS in Amarillo. Many Judges are afraid to rule against them just in case they are right. Often CPS does need to step into situations. Employees are mostly young, book educated w/ litttle, if any actual experience in raising children. They always bring the law with them, you will be arrested if you cause any problems. Child is taken, no clothes, no bottles, no formula instructions, nothing, just child is removed. Even later there are no questions asked about

Friday, Apr 25 at 9:00 AM Anonymous wrote ...

You are right. children should not be seperated from their mothers

Thursday, Apr 24 at 10:46 PM doe wrote ...

Children should not have been separated from their mothers. How would you feel if the government took your children?

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

KAUZ News Channel 6 and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Most Viewed

Weather

Doppler 6000
Lawton : 79 °
Wichita Falls : 81 °
More Weather
High: Friday - 98
Low: Friday Morning - 75
Conditions Today
Overnight - Warm Texoma Night

7 Day Forecast

AP Video

On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.